top of page
  • Writer's pictureBella O

Dealership or Independent Auto Repair Shop?

The decision of where to get your vehicle repaired can be a difficult one. On the one hand, there's the dealership that you bought the vehicle from, and on the other hand, there are independent auto shops that offer quality auto repair services. Both have their pros and cons, but the key difference between auto repair at a dealership and an independent auto shop lies in the areas of expertise, cost, and customer service.

There are several benefits of using a dealership for repairs, including:

1. Expertise: Dealerships have technicians who are specifically trained to work on the vehicles they sell. This means that they have access to the latest technology, software, and training programs, and are equipped with the necessary tools and equipment to perform repairs on your vehicle.

2. Warranty: If your vehicle is still under warranty, the cost of repairs at a dealership will be covered by the warranty, saving you a significant amount of money in the long run.

3. Parts Availability: Dealerships have a vast network of resources, including a parts department, to help diagnose and repair just about any issue that you may encounter with your vehicle. They are able to quickly obtain the parts necessary to repair your vehicle.

4. Customer Service: Dealerships are known for their high level of customer service, from the moment you walk through the door to the moment you leave with your repaired vehicle. They offer a wide range of services, including loaner cars and shuttle services, to make the repair process as convenient as possible for their customers.

5. Trust and Reliability: Dealerships have a reputation for providing quality repairs and excellent customer service. Using a dealership for repairs can give you peace of mind knowing that your vehicle is in good hands.

6. Record Keeping: Dealerships keep a record of all repairs made to your vehicle, which can be helpful if you need to prove that the repairs were performed in the future.

7. Convenience: Dealerships are often located in convenient locations, making it easy to drop off and pick up your vehicle for repairs. They usually offer a wide range of services, including car washes, detailing, and maintenance, making it a one-stop-shop for all your vehicle needs.

While there can be several benefits to using a dealership for repairs, there are also some disadvantages, including:

1. Cost: If your vehicle is no longer under warranty, you can expect to pay higher prices for repairs at a dealership than at an independent auto shop. Dealerships have higher overhead costs associated with running a dealership, which can result in higher prices for repairs.

2. Limited Services: Dealerships may not offer services for non-warranty repairs, such as aftermarket upgrades or customizations, which may be available at independent auto shops.

3. Long Wait Times: Dealerships can be busy and may have long wait times for repairs, especially during peak seasons. This can be frustrating for car owners who need their vehicle repaired quickly.

4. Lack of Personal Touch: Dealerships can be impersonal and may not provide the same level of attention and care as independent auto shops. They may also be less flexible in accommodating your specific needs and preferences.

5. Limited Availability: Dealerships may not be available in all areas, making it difficult for car owners who live in rural or remote areas to access their services.

6. Strict Scheduling: Dealerships may have strict scheduling policies, making it difficult for car owners who have busy schedules to drop off and pick up their vehicles for repairs.

7. Limited Flexibility: Dealerships may not be able to accommodate special requests, such as using specific parts or using non-OEM parts for repairs.

Here are several benefits of using an independent auto shop for repairs, including:

1. Cost: Independent auto shops generally offer lower prices for auto repairs than dealerships. They have lower overhead costs and are able to pass these savings on to their customers. Since they offer competitive pricing and discounts, it makes them an attractive option for those on a tight budget.

2. Expertise: Independent auto shops are known for their vast knowledge base and experience with a wide range of vehicle makes and models. They are able to diagnose and repair a variety of issues, from simple problems to complex repairs, without being limited by the restrictions of a dealership.

3. Specialization: Independent auto shops often specialize in specific areas, such as transmissions, engines, or electrical systems, which can be a great advantage for car owners who are looking for an expert in a particular area of repair.

4. Flexibility: Independent auto shops offer a more relaxed atmosphere and are often willing to go the extra mile to make sure their customers are satisfied with their repairs. They may also be more flexible in accommodating special requests, such as using specific parts or using non-OEM parts for repairs.

5. Quick Turnaround: Independent auto shops often have shorter wait times for repairs, making it easier for car owners who need their vehicle repaired quickly.

6. Customer Service: Independent auto shops are often staffed by a small team of technicians who are passionate about their work. They take pride in their ability to diagnose and repair vehicles, and they are often more personal and approachable than the staff at dealerships. They are often willing to go the extra mile to make sure their customers are satisfied with their repairs. You also have the opportunity to build a lasting relationship with your mechanic and the staff members with the independent shops because they have a greater incentive to satisfy their clients and considerably fewer employees. Independent auto shops offer that more overall personal touch and a more relaxed atmosphere.

7. Convenient Location: Independent auto shops are often located in convenient locations and may be more accessible for car owners who live in rural or remote areas.

In conclusion, while dealerships have the benefits we discussed, more people are choosing independent auto shops for repairs nowadays. According to Consumer Reports polls, independent mechanics outperformed dealership services in terms of client happiness, cost, quality, courtesy, and timely repairs. To sum it up, when Tony, owner of Grease Monkey Garage, was asked – “Is there ever a time or scenario when someone needs to take their car to a dealership versus an independent shop like yours?” He replied, “I would say when the car is under factory warranty and when there is a recall. That’s when I would recommend the Dealer. Other than that, we can handle most issues and the stuff that we can’t we usually send to the dealer for help anyway so it’s kind of like a collaboration if we need them”

So there you have it! If you are looking for an independent certified auto repair facility, we are a family and locally owned auto repair shop. We provide all of Las Vegas & Henderson with leading edge service and quality auto repair.

Call Grease Monkey Garage today for experienced auto repair & maintenance services in Las Vegas & North Las Vegas at 702-478-7881 and in Henderson at 702-478-7027.

Tony & Bella - Owners Grease Monkey Garage
Tony & Bella - Owners Grease Monkey Garage

bottom of page